A Case for Wise Hope in Dark Times.
As we move deeper into the various political and environmental crises upon us, it may be difficult not to yield to despair. In this exceptional Contemplation by Design Keynote, Roshi Joan Halifax makes the case for 'wise hope' and reminds us that hope is an imperative to action in the midst of uncertainty. This excerpt from the The Strange and Necessary Case for Hope is rare medicine for our dark times.
“I have often been troubled by the notion of hope. It just did not seem very Buddhist to hope. The Zen master Shunryu Suzuki Roshi once said that life is “like stepping onto a boat which is about to sail out to sea and sink.” That certainly brings conventional hope up short! But some time ago, in part because of the work of social critic Rebecca Solnit and her powerful book Hope in the Dark, I am opening to another view of hope—what I am calling “wise hope.”
As Buddhists, we know that ordinary hope is based in desire, wanting an outcome that could well be different from what might actually happen. To make matters worse, not getting what we hoped for is often experienced as a misfortune. If we look deeply, we realize that anyone who is conventionally hopeful has an expectation that always hovers in the background, the shadow of fear that one’s wishes will not be fulfilled. Ordinary hope then is a form of suffering. This kind of hope is a nemesis and a partner with fear.”
Hope Is Not Optimism
“We might ask then: what more specifically is hope? Let’s begin by saying what hope is not: hope is not the belief that everything will turn out well. People die. Populations die out. Civilizations die. Planets die. Stars die. Recalling the words of Suzuki Roshi, the boat is going to sink! If we look, we see the evidence of suffering, of injustice, of futility, of desolation, of harm, of ending all around us, and even within us. But we have to understand that hope is not a story based on optimism, that everything will be ok. Optimists imagine that everything will turn out positively. I consider this point of view dangerous; being an optimist means one doesn’t have to bother; one doesn’t have to act. Also, if things don’t turn out well, cynicism or futility often follow. Hope of course is also opposed to the narrative that everything is getting worse, the position that pessimists take. Pessimists take refuge in depressive apathy or apathy driven by cynicism. And, as we might expect, both optimists and pessimists are excused from engagement.
So, what is it to be hopeful and not optimistic? The American novelist Barbara Kingsolver explains it this way: “I have been thinking a lot lately about the difference between being optimistic and being hopeful. I would say that I’m a hopeful person, although not necessarily optimistic. Here’s how I would describe it. The pessimist would say, ‘It’s going to be a terrible winter; we’re all going to die.’ The optimist would say, ‘Oh, it’ll be alright; I don’t think it’ll be that bad. The hopeful person would say, ‘Maybe someone will still be alive in February, so I’m going to put some potatoes in the root cellar just in case.’ … Hope is... a mode of resistance... a gift I can try to cultivate.””
Both Not Knowing and Meaning
“If we look at hope through the lens of Buddhism, we discover that wise hope is born of radical uncertainty, rooted in the unknown and the unknowable. How could we ever know what is really going to happen?! My good friend, the cultural historian William DeBuys, once remarked to me that he places his faith, such as it is, in surprise. Wise hope requires that we open ourselves to what we do not know, what we cannot know; that we open ourselves to being surprised, perpetually surprised. In fact, wise hope comes alive through the spaciousness of radical uncertainty, of surprise, and this is the space in which we can engage. This is what socially engaged Buddhist Joanna Macy calls “active hope,” the engaged expression of wise hope.
It’s when we discern courageously, and at the same time realize we don’t know what will happen that wise hope comes alive; in the midst of improbability and possibility is where the imperative to act rises up. Wise hope is not seeing things unrealistically but rather seeing things as they are, including the truth of impermanence…as well as the truth of suffering—both its existence and the possibility of its transformation, for better or for worse.
Through another Buddhist lens, we can see that hope reflects the understanding that what we do matters, even though how and when it may matter, who and what it may impact, are not things we can really know beforehand. I am recalling the poet Gary Snyder reading the work of the 9th century Chinese poet Han Shan, who fled from the civil servant’s life and took refuge in the mountains, scratching his poems on rocks, bamboo bark, trees, and the walls of houses in neighboring villages. Of course, Han Shan never knew that a 1000 years later, a young guy in a fire watch tower in the Cascade Mountains of the United States of America would read his poetry and inspire what we now know as the environmental movement of deep ecology, a way of seeing our interconnected relationship to the natural world.
Truly, we cannot know what will unfold from our actions now or in the future; yet we can trust that things will change; they always do. But our vows, our actions, how we live, what we care about, what we care for, and how we care really do matter all the same. Rebecca Solnit reminds us that history is full of people whose influence was most powerful after they were gone.
Yet often we become paralyzed by the belief that there is nothing to hope for—that our patient’s cancer diagnosis is a one-way street with no exit, that our political situation is beyond repair, that there is no way out of our climate crisis. Guishan thought that there was no fire left in the hearth. We might feel that nothing makes sense anymore, or that we have no power and there’s no reason to act; that the fire is dead.
In response to the notion of hope and hopelessness, the Theravada monk Thanissaro Bhikkhu reminds us that we are not victims of fate or of a higher power; from this perspective, we can say that hope opens us to a wider horizon and to deeper and unexpected possibilities. We can recall that Guishan’s life opened to a boundless horizon when his teacher Baizhang showed him the glowing ember.”
“I often say that there should be just two words over the door of our Zen temple in Santa Fe: Show up! One might ask why would I want these words over the door of our temple, when despair, defeatism, cynicism, skepticism, and the apathy of forgetting are fed by the corroding effect of conventional hopelessness. Yes, suffering is present. We cannot deny it. There are 67.3 million refugees in the world today; only eleven countries are free from conflict; climate change is turning forests into deserts. Japan’s population is declining. Suicide rates for children are up. Many feel no connection to religion or spirituality, and countless people are deeply alienated and take refuge in their digital devices. We also see that economic injustice is driving people into greater and greater poverty. Racism and sexism remain rampant. Our medical system is deeply challenged. Globalization and neoliberalism are putting the planet at great risk.
The peacemaker Daniel Berrigan once remarked "One cannot level one's moral lance at every evil in the universe. There are just too many of them. But you can do something; and the difference between doing something and doing nothing is everything." Berrigan understood that wise hope doesn’t mean denying the realities that we are confronted with today. It means facing them, addressing them, and remembering what else is present, like the shifts in our values that recognize and move us to address suffering right now. Seven hundred years ago, in Japan, Zen Master Keizan wrote: “Do not find fault with the present.”. He invites us to see it, not flee it!
Returning to the difference between hope and optimism and why hope makes sense in our fraught world, the Czech statesman Václav Havel said, “Hope is definitely not the same thing as optimism. It is not the conviction that something will turn out well but the certainty that something makes sense, regardless of how it turns out.” For many, it feels like an imperative to march for peace, to work for the ending of nuclear proliferation, to put pressure on the US government to re-sign the Paris Agreement on Climate Change. It makes sense to shelter the homeless, including those fleeing from war and climate devastation; it makes sense to support compassion and care in medicine in spite of the increasing presence of technology that stands between patients and clinicians. It makes sense to sit with dying people, take care of our elders, feed the hungry, love and educate our children. In truth, we can’t know how things will turn out, but we can trust that there will be movement, there will be change. And at the same time, something deep inside us affirms what is good and right to do. So we move forward in our day and sit at the bedside of the dying grandmother or teach that third grade class of kids from the poor neighborhood. We bear witness to the young man who wants to take his life. We hold our CEO’s and politicians accountable. Baizhang plunged the fire tongs into the dead ashes. And Barbara Kingsolver put potatoes in her root cellar.
It is exactly at this point of not knowing where our vows come alive... in the midst of seeming futility or meaninglessness. Maybe you know the story told by the great natural scientist Loren Eiseley of the man who is walking down the beach and sees another man tossing starfish back into the sea. The first man says to the second man: Why bother, too many starfish; won’t make any difference. One version of the story has the second man saying, “Well, it made a difference to that one,” as he tosses another starfish back into the ocean.
There is a story told about Dutch-born activist A.J. Muste. Near the end of his long life, during the Vietnam War, Muste stood in front of the White House every night, holding a single lit candle. Often he was alone. One evening, a reporter interviewed him as he stood in the rain. “Mr. Muste,” the reporter said, “do you really think you are going to change the policies of this country by standing out here alone at night with a candle?” Muste replied, “Oh, I don’t do this to change the country. I do this so the country won’t change me.”
The Talmud states: “Do not be daunted by the enormity of the world's grief. Do justly, now. Love mercy, now. Walk humbly, now. You are not obligated to complete the work, but neither are you free to abandon it.”
The American Zen teacher Peter Levitt reflected on this sentiment when he wrote that “many people think that a mitzvah, a good deed, is something special. The teaching is that it is not; it is an obligation. We are obliged to do mitzvahs. We don't do them because we are special, or particularly good people. We do them because that is what a human being does as an expression of what a human being is. So, yes; we are not obliged to complete the work, but we ARE obliged to undertake it in a way that helps the world to realize its wholeness, from the very beginning. It is part of the joy of being alive.”
Our vows and wise hope are what Zen Master Dogen means when he admonishes us to “give life to life,” even if it’s just one starfish at a time, one dying person at a time, one refugee at a time, one man in front of our nation’s capital with a single candle in his hand.”
Richard Rohr, as a Catholic priest and Franciscan Friar, will offer a concise history of how Western Christianity once had, soon lost, tried to retrieve, and now is roundly rediscovering its own traditional understanding of unitive consciousness
In a rare meeting of minds, and a rare exploration of whether there is a predilection for spirituality, Gabor Mate asks Adyashanti to expand on passages from his recent book My Secret Is Silence.
"It is not a person that is waking up, it is consciousness."
Speaking at the 2018 Radiant Intimacy gathering, Esther Perel outlines the remarkable transformation…
Peter Russell explains that most human beings—unlike animals—focus on the past and the future, which means they spend their time in a state of discontent.
Aisha Salem talks of being willing to let go of our limitations, of keeping ourselves small, and of living our individuality
Eric Baret points out that there are no sculptures of yogic asanas in Indian temples before the modern era. He describes today’s yoga as a commercial project...
Speaking at the 2018 Radiant Intimacy gathering, Justin Garcia, evolutionary biologist at the Kinsey…
Awakened living realizes that the absolute and the relative dimensions of our Being are simply “not-two.”
What may or may not be appropriate behavior for a spiritual teacher?
Dzogchen, the bardo, sleep and the yoga of dreams
In this memorable conversation from SAND 18 Peter Levine, the father of trauma therapy work, and Thomas Huebl, a spiritual teacher known for his work integrating healing of collective trauma, discuss the relationship between healing trauma and...
Francis Lucille answers questions from the audience at SAND 18, bringing his intelligence and wit to a variety of topics
Nadeshwari Joythimayananda describes the image and the symbolism and the energy of the goddess Tripura Sundari
Eric Baret explains clearly that there is no need for the self to appropriate achievement
An immersive visual meditative journey with Rupert Spira
The Yamabushi in northern Japan practice a once forbidden ancient religion. While their tradition is at risk of disappearing, it offers a way for those seeking a different path in Japan‘s society.
Creativity can be seen as a state of natural flow...
Ellen Emmet explains her understanding of the role of the body in our exploration of truth...
In this exclusive interview with Dr. Alan Wallace we discuss consciousness, mathematics, practicing deep sleep states and meditation as preparation for dying consciously.
In straight talk from the 2018 Radiant Intimacy gathering, Esther Perel offers fresh insights into expectations,…
Bob Thurman delights the audience at SAND 2018 with his lighthearted approach to the wisdom and the…
Excerpt from Let the Moon Be Free, by Eric Baret What disturbs you in the presence of someone else is…
Many traditions and mystics talk about nondualism. But what is nondualism, and how have people—from different religions in different parts of the word—described this concept over time?
The universe is dreaming us up and we are all dreaming our lives into being.
I am a seeker who feels he has arrived, in that, these days, I both intellectually and feeling-wise, experience a oneness that is a great joy and comfort - completely unknowing, absolutely wondrous, constantly available, not really what I expected
Kashmir Shaivism encompasses a vast territory of wisdom and knowledge about the universe and a human…
Please, please don’t worry. How many times do I have to say it?
There is a pervasive myth about enlightenment which, although repeated by many spiritual teachers, has its origins in a view of spirituality that arises from the misconceptions of the unhealed ego.
In a now famous conversation between Carl Sagan and the Dalai Lama, Sagan, a scientist and renowned…
Ellen Emmet explains her understanding of the role of the body in our exploration of truth...
I have this concern about what is happening in the world. If we take nonduality really seriously, it seems like we are not concerned about the exterior.
I have to confess that I was a little taken aback at breakfast this morning when Ellen and I sat down, and Zaya and Maurizio came to sit down with us.
Look deeper. Look deeper at your mala, your skateboard, your yoga mat. Look deeper at your records,…
Durga is a Goddess of Strength and Justice who brings compassion, peace, calm and order to the chaos, destruction and conflict in any situation.
The contemplative spirituality of via feminina begins with the practice of gestation.
From the dualistic thinking of the first half of life into the contemplative mind of the integrated self
Emotions are tricky entities. They confuse the mind and disturb perception, isolating an individual in a private sense of reality. So what to do with them?
Entering into that territory where the practices that have sustained us no longer can guide us in the terrain we are in.
Recognizing that our bodies and our sexuality are sacred is a good way to begin undoing the split between sex and spirit...
Asking a question is being the most active you can be. It means being humble. Humility is the most active attitude.
For decades I was conditioned to believe that to engage a mature spiritual life I needed to “pick one tradition and go deep,”
Tantra in the Western imagination stands for exotic and orgasmic rituals coming from India and Tibet that blend sex and meditation.
There is one fundamental presumption upon which our world culture is founded. This basic presumption states that experience is divided into two essential elements – a subject and an object – joined together by an act of knowing, feeling or perceiving.
The path of reality is not a path, for it is an exploration of life in all that it is...
Obviously, that’s an important question for nondualists including Advaitins and Buddhists.
For me it is irrelevant, but let’s say for the Kashmirian tradition, as far as my teacher expressed…
Seeking is an expression of truth, it’s not a way. Abhinavagupta, in the Tantraloka, is very clear; all the yoga practices are an expression of truth. Yoga does not bring us to truth, truth expresses itself through yoga.
French paraphrase of the original Buddhist text by J. Garillot (1974), translated by Else van den Muyzenberg.…
Quantum particles, the foundation of the universe, are like naughty children playing catch me if you can with scientists in a game with no rules.
Please enter your email and we’ll send you instructions to reset your password